Skip to main content

Why Growing Companies Stall

The CEO Tolerance Trap

Your culture sits between what you insist on and what you tolerate. When tolerating wins, growth stalls and every decision lands back on your desk.

What the Trap Looks Like

Every company has a standard, written or not. It shows up in the behaviors, habits, and routines you insist on through your core values, your strategy, and your execution. The other half of your culture is how long you let people violate that standard.

The CEO tolerance trap is what happens when that window stays open too long. You keep C players well past the point you know they need to go. Leaders protect systems they should be improving because changing them is uncomfortable. You keep stepping in to solve problems your team could solve on their own, and they learn to bring you every one.

None of it feels like a decision. It builds one quarter at a time, until the company can only grow as fast as you can work.

Five Signs You're in It

You can name your C players

And they've been on the team longer than two quarters since you first noticed.

Your best people are leaving

Or they've stopped pushing. Tolerating C players is the number one reason A players leave.

The same fires keep coming back

Leaders say everything is fine, and nobody owns fixing the system behind the problem.

Your team brings you their problems

Including the ones they could solve themselves. You've become the rescuer.

Your core values live on the wall

Nobody gets measured against them, so they stop meaning anything.

What It Costs

~30%

The drag a C player usually puts on a team's critical KPI. Rob sees it consistently across clients, in every department.

10–15%

The odds that a C player truly changes their behavior.

0

Times Rob has heard a leader say, "I should have held onto that C player longer."

How to Get Out

  1. 1. Define the standard

    Rank your core values from most to least important so they work as a decision-making tool. When two values pull in different directions, the ranking decides.

  2. 2. Rate every seat

    A C player is someone who falls well below your standard on productivity and core values. That covers how they treat the team as much as what they produce.

  3. 3. Put a clock on it

    Give someone a quarter or two to improve. If they don't, make the change in a way that's consistent with your values, and help them land somewhere better suited to them.

  4. 4. Hire better up front

    Topgrading interviews can raise your odds of hiring an A player from about 25% to as high as 90% when you run the process well. Every good hire is one less person to remove later.

  5. 5. Coach through obstacles instead of rescuing

    Hold weekly one-on-ones. When someone brings you a problem they can solve, ask "What do you recommend?" and let them own the answer.

This is the People work inside the Scaling Up business operating system, and the first decision in the Four Decisions Workshop.

See How Much You're Tolerating

The Growth Readiness Assessment scores your People, Strategy, Execution, and Cash in about 15 minutes. Rob reviews every result personally.